
Why Keys Snap — and Why the Fragment Is the Real Problem
Keys are under more mechanical stress than most people realize. Every time a key is inserted and turned, the blade flexes slightly against the pins or wafers inside the cylinder. Over months and years, microscopic cracks develop near the bow — the part you grip — or at any point where the blade has been thinned by wear. Brass and nickel-silver keys are particularly susceptible once they pass a certain age. Add a cylinder that has not been lubricated, a lock that has shifted slightly in a door frame after settling (common in Edison's older colonial-style homes in the Bonhamtown and Pines neighborhoods), or a cold morning that has stiffened the mechanism, and the conditions for a clean snap are in place. The break itself takes only a fraction of a second.
The more urgent problem is what the fragment does once it is inside the lock. It wedges against the shear line, preventing the pins from aligning even if you have a perfect duplicate key. Attempting to pry it out with a bobby pin, paperclip, or pocket knife risks pushing the fragment deeper, scoring the cylinder walls, or damaging the pins themselves — any of which can turn a straightforward extraction into a cylinder replacement. The right move is to stop forcing the mechanism and call a professional. Our technicians carry purpose-built broken key extractors in multiple profiles to match the keyway, along with fine pick tools that allow them to manipulate the fragment out without wedging it further.

